Tuesday, 14 June 2011

Paper on ECHR and Extraterritoriality

Barbara Miltner of the University of Cambridge has published a paper on Bepress on the extraterritorial application of the ECHR. It is entitled 'Revisiting Extraterritoriality: the ECHR and its Lessons' and connects the scope of the ECHR in Article 1 to the so-called 'colonial clause'. This is the abstract:

The extraterritorial scope of international human rights treaties has prompted vigorous debate in recent years. Much of this debate has focused on earlier developments in the European Court of Human Rights as well as the comparative jurisprudence of other international human rights treaties, with a particular focus on the concept of jurisdiction. This article refocuses the inquiry from a broad-spectrum comparative approach to an in-depth case study examining the complex interplay of factors influencing the extraterritorial application of the European Convention on Human Rights. While prior articles have focused nearly exclusively on its general jurisdiction clause, this paper recognises the equally significant contribution of a second, poorly understood treaty provision about which very little has been written. It goes on to examine the historical context and drafting history of these two key provisions prior to tracing what can be termed their irreconcilable jurisprudential evolution. What it reveals is a complex interaction between two provisions that defies facile characterization and militates against a one-size-fits all approach across human rights treaties.
Note that the paper still has a lot of track changes in it - hopefully that can be changed by the author soon in order to make the reading easier.

1 comment:

CIHC said...

After reading your blog, I thought that some of your followers might be interested in attending a Human Rights & Humanitarian Law Course offered by the Center for International Humanitarian Cooperation.

Our Human Rights and Humanitarian Law course offers participants an understanding of the origins and principles of these two bodies of law. It is crucial for humanitarian aid workers to understand the legal aspect of their work so they are able to conduct effective relief in accordance to all necessary procedures and protocols. Examining different case studies will foster useful analytical learning skills that can be integrated in the students’ future field experiences. A thorough comprehension of both sets of laws will enable students to gain more legal confidence in their aid work, it will promote a greater understanding of the logistics and legitimacies of how issues are handled.
This is a multi-disciplinary training program for students from a variety of backgrounds and experiences. All participants are required to have a university degree and to be at least 25 years old. Preference will be given to students with humanitarian field experience, emergency or development. All courses are conducted in English.

The course will take place from September 4 – September 10, 2001 in Nairobi, Kenya.

For more information, including instructions on how to apply, please visit our website www.cihc.org/